Xbox Game Pass has long promised subscribers an “endless library” of games. But that dream took a hit with the announcement that the console exclusive Stalker 2: Heart of Chornobyl will leave the platform in November. This news disappointed many and raised questions about the true nature of Game Pass.

The Illusion of an Endless Library

Game Pass isn’t a purchase—it’s a content rental service. When licensing deals end, games are removed from the library.

• Expectation: Many gamers assumed that a major console exclusive like Stalker 2 would remain on Game Pass permanently, just like Halo.

• Reality: Stalker 2 isn’t a first-party Xbox title; it’s a third-party game available through a licensing agreement. Even its console exclusive status didn’t guarantee its stay on Game Pass.

Player Frustration and Trust Issues

This removal was a harsh reminder for subscribers: you don’t “own” games on Game Pass—you’re just renting access. Some disappointed users are now asking, “If even the biggest exclusives can leave, why should I keep my subscription?”

The only way Xbox can address this is by being more transparent about how long third-party games will remain on Game Pass and managing expectations clearly.

Game Pass still offers incredible value, but the Stalker 2 case has exposed a crack that could affect gamers’ trust in the service.